Adam Silver is writing a book on forms — you may be familiar with his previous book on maintainable CSS. In a recent article (that for some reason isn’t on his blog), he looks at markup patterns for search forms and advocates that we should always use a label. I agree. But for some reason, we keep getting handed designs that show unlabelled search forms. And no, a placeholder is not a label.
I had a discussion with Mark about this the other day. The form he was marking up didn’t have a label, but it did have a button with some text that would work as a label:
<input type="search" placeholder="…">
He was wondering if there was a way of using the button’s text as the label. I think there is. Using aria-labelledby like this, the button’s text should be read out before the input field:
<input aria-labelledby="searchtext" type="search" placeholder="…">
<button type="submit" id="searchtext">
Notice that I say “think” and “should.” It’s one thing to figure out a theoretical solution, but only testing will show whether it actually works.
The W3C’s WAI tutorial on labelling content gives an example that uses aria-label instead:
<input type="text" name="search" aria-label="Search">
It seems a bit of a shame to me that the label text is duplicated in the button and in the aria-label attribute (and being squirrelled away in an attribute, it runs the risk of metacrap rot). But they know what they’re talking about so there may well be very good reasons to prefer duplicating the value with aria-label rather than pointing to the value with aria-labelledby.
I thought it would be interesting to see how other sites are approaching this pattern — unlabelled search forms are all too common. All the markup examples here have been simplified a bit, removing class attributes and the like…
The BBC’s search form does actually have a label:
Search the BBC
<input id="orb-search-q" placeholder="Search" type="text">
<button>Search the BBC</button>
But that label is then hidden using CSS:
clip: rect(1px, 1px, 1px, 1px);
That CSS — as pioneered by Snook — ensures that the label is visually hidden but remains accessible to assistive technology. Using something like display: none would hide the label for everyone.
Medium wraps the input (and icon) in a label and then gives the label a title attribute. Like aria-label, a title attribute should be read out by screen readers, but it has the added advantage of also being visible as a tooltip on hover:
<label title="Search Medium">
This approach is generally less reliable and not recommended because some screen readers and assistive technologies do not interpret the title attribute as a replacement for the label element, possibly because the title attribute is often used to provide non-essential information.
Twitter follows the BBC’s pattern of having a label but visually hiding it. They also have some descriptive text for the icon, and that text gets visually hidden too:
<label class="visuallyhidden" for="search-query">Search query</label>
<input id="search-query" placeholder="Search Twitter" type="text">
<button type="submit" class="Icon" tabindex="-1">
<span class="visuallyhidden">Search Twitter</span>
Here’s their CSS for hiding those bits of text — it’s very similar to the BBC’s:
clip: rect(0 0 0 0);
<input placeholder="Photos, people, or groups" aria-label="Search" type="text">
<input type="submit" value="Search">
Interestingly, neither Twitter or Flickr are using type=”search” on the input elements. I’m guessing this is probably because of frustrations with trying to undo the default styles that some browsers apply to input type=”search” fields. Seems a shame though.
Instagram also doesn’t use type=”search” and makes no attempt to expose any kind of accessible label:
<input type="text" placeholder="Search">
Same with Tumblr:
<input tabindex="1" type="text" name="q" id="search_query" placeholder="Search Tumblr" autocomplete="off" required="required">
…although the search form itself does have role=”search” applied to it. Perhaps that helps to mitigate the lack of a clear label?
After that whistle-stop tour of a few of the web’s unlabelled search forms, it looks like the options are:
- a visually-hidden label element,
- an aria-label attribute,
- a title attribute, or
- associate some text using aria-labelledby.
But that last one needs some testing.
This was originally posted on my own site.