I was listening to some items in my Huffduffer feed when I noticed a little bit of synchronicity.
First of all, I was listening to Tom talking about Thington, and he mentioned seamful design — the idea that “seamlessness” is not necessarily a desirable quality. I think that’s certainly true in the world of connected devices.
Then I listened to Jeff interviewing Matt about hardware startups. They didn’t mention seamful design specifically (it was more all cricket and cables), but again, I think it’s a topic that’s lurking behind any discussion of the internet of things.
I’ve written about seams before. I really feel there’s value — and empowerment — in exposing the points of connection in a system. When designers attempt to airbrush those seams away, I worry that they are moving from “Don’t make me think” to “Don’t allow me to think”.
In many ways, aiming for seamlessness in design feels like the easy way out. It’s a surface-level approach that literally glosses over any deeper problems. I think it might be driven my an underlying assumption that seams are, by definition, ugly. Certainly there are plenty of daily experiences where the seams are noticeable and frustrating. But I don’t think it needs to be this way. The real design challenge is to make those seams beautiful.
This was originally posted on my own site.