Name That Script! by Trent Walton
Trent is about to pop his AEA cherry and give a talk at An Event Apart in Boston. I’m going to attempt to liveblog this:
How many third-party scripts are loading on our web pages these days? How can we objectively measure the value of these (advertising, a/b testing, analytics, etc.) scripts — considering their impact on web performance, user experience, and business goals? We’ve learned to scrutinize content hierarchy, browser support, and page speed as part of the design and development process. Similarly, Trent will share recent experiences and explore ways to evaluate and discuss the inclusion of 3rd-party scripts.
Trent is going to speak about third-party scripts, which is funny, because a year ago, he never would’ve thought he’d be talking about this. But he realised he needed to pay more attention to:
any request made to an external URL.
Or how about this:
A resource included with a web page that the site owner doesn’t explicitly control.
When you include a third-party script, the third party can change the contents of that script.
Here are some uses:
- A/B testing,
- social media,
- content delivery networks,
- customer interaction,
- tag managers,
You get data from things like analytics and A/B testing. You get income from ads. You get content from CDNs.
But Trent has concerns. First and foremost, the user experience effects of poor performance. Also, there are the privacy implications.
Why does Trent — a designer — care about third party scripts? Well, over the years, the areas that Trent pays attention to has expanded. He’s progressed from image comps to frontend to performance to accessibility to design systems to the command line and now to third parties. But Trent has no impact on those third-party scripts. That’s very different to all those other areas.
Trent mostly builds prototypes. Those then get handed over for integration. Sometimes that means hooking it up to a CMS. Sometimes it means adding in analytics and ads. It gets really complex when you throw in third-party comments, payment systems, and A/B testing tools. Oftentimes, those third-party scripts can outweigh all the gains made beforehand. It happens with no discussion. And yet we spent half a meeting discussing a border radius value.
Delivering a performant, accessible, responsive, scalable website isn’t enough: I also need to consider the impact of third-party scripts.
Trent has spent the last few months learning about third parties so he can be better equiped to discuss them.
UX, performance and privacy impact
We feel the UX impact every day we browse the web (if we turn off our content blockers). The Food Network site has an intersitial asking you to disable your ad blocker. They promise they won’t spawn any pop-up windows. Trent turned his ad blocker off — the page was now 15 megabytes in size. And to top it off …he got a pop up.
Privacy can harder to perceive. We brush aside cookie notifications. What if the wording was “accept trackers” instead of “accept cookies”?
Remarketing is that experience when you’re browsing for a spatula and then every website you visit serves you ads for spatula. That might seem harmless but allowing access to our browsing history has serious privacy implications.
Web builders are on the front lines. It’s up to us to advocate for data protection and privacy like we do for web standards. Don’t wait to be told.
Categories of third parties
Ghostery categories third-party providers: advertising, comments, customer interaction, essential, site analytics, social media. You can dive into each layer and see the specific third-party services on the page you’re viewing.
Analyse and itemise third-party scripts
We have “view source” for learning web development. For third parties, you need some tool to export the data. HAR files (HTTP ARchive) are JSON files that you can create from most browsers’ network request panel in dev tools. But what do you do with a
.har file? The site har.tech has plenty of resources for you. That’s where Trent found the Mac app, Charles. It can open
.har files. Best of all, you can export to CSV so you can share spreadsheets of the data.
You can visualise third-party requests with Simon Hearne’s excellent Request Map. It’s quite impactful for delivering a visceral reaction in a meeting — so much more effective than just saying “hey, we have a lot of third parties.” Request Map can also export to CSV.
Know industry averages
Trent wanted to know what was “normal.” He decided to analyse HAR files for Alexa’s top 50 US websites. The result was a massive spreadsheet of third-party providers. There were 213 third-party domains (which is not even the same as the number of requests). There was an average of 22 unique third-party domains per site. The usual suspects were everywhere — Google, Amazon, Facebook, Adobe — but there were many others. You can find an alphabetical index on better.fyi/trackers. Often the lesser-known domains turn out to be owned by the bigger domains.
News sites and shopping sites have the most third-party scripts, unsurprisingly.
Trent realised he needed to listen and understand why third-party scripts are being included. He found out what tag managers do. They’re funnels that allow you to cram even more third-party scripts onto your website. Trent worried that this was a Pandora’s box. The tag manager interface is easy to access and use. But he was told that it’s more like a way of organising your third-party scripts under one dashboard. But still, if you get too focused on the dashboard, you could lose focus of the impact on load times. So don’t blame the tool: it’s all about how it’s used.
Establish a centre of excellence. Put standards in place — in a cross-discipline way — to define how third-party scripts are evaluated. For example:
- Determine the value to the business.
- Avoid redundant scripts and services.
- Fit within the established performance budget.
Document those decisions, maybe even in your design system.
Also, include third-party scripts within your prototypes to get a more accurate feel for the performance implications.
On a live site, you can regularly audit third-party scripts on a regular basis. Check to see if any are redundant or if they’re exceeding the performance budget. You can monitor performance with tools like Calibre and Speed Curve to cover the time in between audits.
Make your case
Do competitive analysis. Look at other sites in your sector. It’s a compelling way to make a case for change. WPO Stats is very handy for anecdata.
You can gather comparative data with Web Page Test: you can run a full test, and you can run a test with certain third parties blocked. Use the results to kick off a discussion about the impact of those third parties.
Talk it out
Work to maintain an ongoing discussion with the entire team. As Tim Kadlec says:
Everything should have a value, because everything has a cost.
This was originally posted on my own site.